By Steve Levine
Technically no. It is court-ordered restitution from a Massachusetts Attorney General enforcement action that went to trial in December 2024. The Court ruled in favor of the AGO in early 2026, ordering approximately $4 million in restitution to about 47,000 affected Massachusetts consumers.
Approximately 47,000 Massachusetts BSC members identified by the Court as having been unfairly billed during the COVID-19 closure period (mid-March through July 2020) and who have not yet been compensated through previous refunds or credits.
Total restitution is approximately $4 million across 47,000 members. Per-person amounts vary based on each member's specific unfair billing minus any previous refunds or account credits already received from BSC. Average is roughly $85.
No traditional claim form. Log into the refund website with the Claim Number and PIN from the email the Refund Administrator (Analytics Consulting LLC) sent you, and select your preferred payment method (Zelle or paper check). Consumers who do nothing still receive a default payment from the Refund Administrator.
No. The Court already determined eligibility from BSC's own transaction data at trial. The Claim Number and PIN from your email is the only thing you need to log in.
Former CEO Patrick Walsh billed BSC members for April 2020 even though all gyms were closed for COVID-19. The Court also found BSC thwarted member cancellation requests and violated the Massachusetts Health Club Act.
The BSC brand was retired in a 2023 Town Sports International restructuring. The Boston-area gyms now operate under the New York Sports Club brand, with three former BSC locations open in Massachusetts under the new name.
Select your payment method by June 16, 2026, or within 90 days of receiving the email notice from the Refund Administrator. Consumers who do nothing still receive a default payment but may have to wait longer.
Status: Open
Pre-Qualify
Pre-Qualify Here
Submit Claim
Pro Rata Cash · No Proof for Up to 5 Modules
Submit Claim
Deadline: August 27, 2026
Submit Claim
Deadline: June 30, 2026
Submit Claim
Est. $40–$200 Cash · No Proof Required
Submit Claim| BSC COVID Refund Snapshot | |
| Status | Refunds Being Distributed Now (AGO announced March 18, 2026) |
|---|---|
| Type | Government enforcement action restitution (not a private class action settlement) |
| Total Restitution | Approximately $4 million |
| Number of Eligible Consumers | Approximately 47,000 Massachusetts BSC members |
| Per-Member Refund | Varies by individual; average roughly $85, calculated from each member's specific April 2020 unfair billing offset by previous refunds or credits |
| Refund Deadline | Tuesday, June 16, 2026 (or within 90 days of receiving the email notice) |
| Claim Form Required? | No; log in with Claim Number and PIN from email to select payment method (or do nothing for default payment) |
| Proof Required? | No (Court-determined eligibility from BSC transaction data) |
| Payment Methods | Zelle (faster) or paper check by U.S. mail |
| Eligibility Period | BSC membership during the COVID-19 closures from mid-March 2020 through July 2020, with unfair billing for April 2020 not previously refunded |
| Case Title | Commonwealth of Massachusetts v. Town Sports International, LLC d/b/a Boston Sports Club and others |
| Court | Suffolk County Superior Court, Commonwealth of Massachusetts |
| Trial Date | December 2024 |
| Ruling Date | Early 2026 (AGO announced March 18, 2026) |
| Defendants | Town Sports International, LLC d/b/a Boston Sports Club; Patrick Walsh (former CEO, personally liable) |
| Plaintiff | Commonwealth of Massachusetts, represented by Attorney General Andrea Joy Campbell |
| Refund Administrator | Analytics Consulting LLC |
| Allegations Proven at Trial | (1) unfair billing for April 2020 while gyms were closed; (2) deceptive statements to members; (3) violations of the Massachusetts Health Club Act by thwarting cancellation requests |
| BSC Closure Period | Mid-March 2020 through July 2020 (COVID-19 pandemic) |
| Current Brand Status | Boston Sports Clubs brand retired in 2023 TSI restructuring; remaining Boston-area gyms now operate under the New York Sports Club brand |
| Category | COVID-19 Refund / AG Enforcement / Consumer Protection / Gym Membership |
| Official Website | Boston Sports Clubs - Official Refund Website |