Insurance · Claims Open

Meridian Security Texas Depreciation Settlement — 51.5% of Withheld Labor Depreciation Plus Interest

Published November 18, 2026

Texas property owners insured by Meridian Security Insurance Company who made a structural damage claim between November 15, 2020 and November 22, 2022 and had labor or other nonmaterial depreciation withheld may qualify to claim 51.5% of that amount plus interest from the Meridian depreciation class action settlement. Claims are due March 17, 2027, and the final approval hearing is set for December 17, 2026.

Homeowners insurance claim form

Current Status

Claims are open. A claim form must be submitted online before midnight Central Time on March 17, 2027, or mailed with a postmark no later than that date. The Franklin County, Ohio Court of Common Pleas granted preliminary approval on July 24, 2026, and the final approval hearing is set for December 17, 2026 at 1:30 p.m. The deadlines to opt out and to object passed on November 17, 2026. No payment goes out until the court grants final approval and any appeals are resolved.

Status Claims Open
Claim Deadline March 17, 2027 Online before midnight Central Time · or postmarked by that date
Payment 51.5% of withheld amount + interest $25 to $500 if the depreciation was later paid back · no cap or fund to divide
Proof Required Yes Unique ID and PIN from the mailed claim form · policy and claim numbers

What Changed Recently?

The opt-out and objection deadlines passed on November 17, 2026, a month before the December 17 final approval hearing. The claim window stays open until March 17, 2027, 90 days after the hearing date.

The case is Walter v. Meridian Security Insurance Co., No. 26-CV-003624, in the Court of Common Pleas of Franklin County, Ohio; the settlement website also uses the caption Barker v. Meridian. It grew out of a federal suit filed November 15, 2022 in the Western District of Texas (No. 5:22-cv-01243), which alleged that Meridian improperly deducted nonmaterial depreciation, such as labor, from actual cash value payments on Texas structural loss claims. The parties had that case administratively closed and refiled in Ohio in April 2026 to present the settlement. Meridian denies all of the allegations and any wrongdoing, and the settlement is not an admission of liability.

The same Ohio case also names Liberty Mutual Personal Insurance Company, Liberty Insurance Corporation and Safeco Insurance Company of Indiana. The court separately preliminarily approved a settlement with those insurers covering their own Texas personal-lines policyholders. This page covers only the Meridian settlement.

Who Qualifies?

The settlement class is everyone who, from November 15, 2020 to November 22, 2022, was issued a Texas property policy by Meridian, made a structural loss claim under Coverage A or Coverage B, had a Symbility or Xactimate estimate used to calculate the actual cash value payment, and had nonmaterial depreciation withheld from that payment, or would have been paid if the withheld nonmaterial depreciation had not pushed the loss below the deductible.

Structural loss covers physical damage to a home, building, manufactured home, condo, rental dwelling or other structure in Texas under a commercial, homeowners, manufactured home, condo, dwelling or rental property policy. Excluded are policyholders whose policy language expressly allowed depreciating labor, whose payments exhausted the policy limits, whose claims were denied or abandoned for other reasons, or for whom Meridian generated no Xactimate or Symbility estimate, along with Meridian, its officers and directors, the judges on the case and class counsel.

How Much Can You Get?

Meridian pays each valid claim directly; there is no common fund to divide, so payments are not reduced by the number of claims. The amount depends on whether the withheld depreciation was ever paid back: Payments are subject to each policy's terms, coverage limits and deductibles. A policyholder with more than one covered loss gets a separate claim form for each loss. Settlement checks expire 120 days after they are issued. A claimant who disagrees with the amount or a denial can ask for review by a neutral evaluator, whose decision is final.

Class counsel will ask for up to $992,000 in attorneys' fees and expenses and up to $7,500 for the class representative. Meridian pays those amounts and all administration costs separately, so they do not reduce class members' payments.

What Proof or Notice ID Is Required?

Filing online requires the Unique ID and PIN printed on the claim form mailed to each potential class member. The form asks the claimant to confirm the insured's name, address, policy number, claim number and date of loss, and to sign it. Claims filed by a legally authorized representative of a deceased or incapacitated policyholder, or by a contractor the claim was assigned to, need supporting documentation. Anyone who did not receive a claim form can request one from the administrator through the settlement website.

What Is the Deadline?

Claim forms must be submitted on the settlement website before midnight Central Time on March 17, 2027, or mailed with a postmark no later than March 17, 2027. The opt-out and objection deadlines were November 17, 2026, and have passed.

How Do You Take Action?

Claims are filed through the claim login page on the official settlement website using the Unique ID and PIN, or by signing and mailing the paper claim form that came with the notice. After an online submission, the website emails a confirmation code.

What Happens Next?

The court will consider final approval, the fee request and the service award at the December 17, 2026 hearing at 1:30 p.m. in Courtroom 6B of the Franklin County Common Pleas Courthouse in Columbus; the hearing can be moved or held by video. After the claim deadline, Meridian calculates each payment, and checks are mailed with a letter once the settlement becomes final. No payment date has been set.

Sources and Verification



Questions

What is nonmaterial depreciation?

When an insurer pays the actual cash value of a damaged structure, it subtracts depreciation from the replacement cost. The lawsuit challenged depreciating labor, equipment, removal and overhead and profit, not just materials. In the settlement, nonmaterial depreciation means the labor, equipment and overhead-and-profit settings in Symbility estimating software, or the depreciate removal, non-material and O&P settings in Xactimate.

What if Meridian already paid the depreciation back later?

Then the payment comes from a fixed schedule instead of the 51.5% formula: $25 if the nonmaterial depreciation was under $5,001, rising in steps to $500 if it was more than $80,000.

Is there one claim per policyholder or per loss?

Per loss. The claim form says a policyholder with more than one covered loss in the class period receives a separate claim form for each loss, and each one must be completed and returned to be paid for that loss.

Can a contractor who was assigned the insurance claim file?

Yes, if the claim was assigned in the ordinary course before preliminary approval to a contractor who did or will do the repair work. The assignee must attach the written assignment and agree to indemnify Meridian if the policyholder also files or disputes the payment.

Official Settlement Notice

Your browser does not support viewing PDFs inline. Download the PDF.


For more class actions keep scrolling below.
Settlement Amount 51.5% of withheld nonmaterial depreciation + interest Paid per valid claim · no common fund · fees paid separately
Case Title Walter v. Meridian Security Insurance Co.
Case Number 26-CV-003624
Court Court of Common Pleas, Franklin County, Ohio
Final Approval Hearing December 17, 2026 at 1:30 PM Courtroom 6B, Columbus · may be held by video
Administrator Epiq Class Action & Claims Solutions

More Insurance Depreciation Settlements