A peremptory challenge lets a lawyer in a jury trial remove a prospective juror without giving any reason, up to a fixed number of strikes set by law. Since Batson v. Kentucky in 1986, those strikes cannot be based on race or sex, and Arizona has abolished them entirely.
Free settlement alerts
Join thousands of readers who get the latest class action settlements you may qualify for — delivered straight to your inbox.
A peremptory challenge is a limited number of strikes each side gets during jury selection to remove a prospective juror without stating a reason. It differs from a challenge for cause, which requires showing the court a specific reason, such as bias, that the person cannot serve fairly.
It depends on the court and the type of case. In federal civil trials, 28 U.S.C. § 1870 gives each party three, and the judge may treat several plaintiffs or several defendants as one party or allow more. In federal criminal trials, Federal Rule of Criminal Procedure 24(b) gives each side 20 in a capital case and 3 in a misdemeanor case; in a felony case the government gets 6 and the defense 10. State courts set their own numbers.
The U.S. Supreme Court held in Batson v. Kentucky (1986) that the Equal Protection Clause bars prosecutors from striking jurors because of race, and later extended the rule to civil cases, to criminal defense lawyers and to strikes based on sex. When a strike is challenged, the lawyer must give a reason unrelated to race or sex, and the judge decides whether that reason is genuine.
A Batson challenge is an objection that the other side used a peremptory strike for a discriminatory reason. The court follows three steps: the objecting party makes an initial showing that discrimination may be at work, the striking party offers a neutral explanation, and the judge decides whether the explanation is believable or a pretext.
Arizona became the first state to do so. An Arizona Supreme Court order entered in August 2021 removed peremptory challenges from both civil and criminal jury trials in state court beginning January 1, 2022. Washington and California kept peremptory strikes but adopted stricter tests for objections that a strike was biased.
A class action that goes to a jury trial uses the same jury selection rules as any other civil case in that court. Most class actions settle before trial, so jury selection is uncommon in them, but it does occur in cases that are tried, including bellwether trials in mass tort litigation.