Pre-Shift Side Work: Tipped Employees, the Tip Credit, and the 80/20 Rule
By Steve Levine · Updated July 2, 2026 · 8 min read
Quick Answer
Pre-shift side work is the non-serving labor tipped restaurant workers do before (and after) waiting tables — rolling silverware, brewing coffee, stocking stations, prep, and cleaning. The fight is over the pay rate: the FLSA lets employers pay tipped employees a cash wage as low as $2.13/hour by taking a tip credit, but side work earns no tips while it's being done. For decades the 80/20 rule capped how much non-tipped work could ride on the sub-minimum wage; the DOL's 2021 version (80/20 plus a 30-minute continuous-work limit) was vacated by the Fifth Circuit in Restaurant Law Center v. DOL (2024), leaving the area governed by the older dual-jobs regulation and developing case law. Standardized side-work checklists make these claims natural FLSA collective actions.
What Side Work Is
Every server knows the routine: arrive before the doors open to roll silverware, brew the
coffee and tea, stock the service stations, cut lemons, portion dressings, wipe menus — then
stay after close to break it all down and clean. Restaurants call it side work, and it
is a structural feature of the job, usually assigned by checklist and enforced by managers.
None of it is controversial as work. The controversy is the rate. A server on a
tipped sub-minimum cash wage earns tips while waiting tables; while rolling silverware in an
empty dining room, the same worker earns the sub-minimum cash wage and nothing else. When the
untipped portion of the shift grows large enough, paying it at the tipped rate starts to look
like wage theft — and when
the side work happens before clock-in entirely, it becomes an
off-the-clock work
claim on top.
The Tip Credit — $2.13 and Its Conditions
The FLSA allows employers of “tipped employees” — workers who customarily and
regularly receive more than $30 a month in tips — to pay a direct cash wage of as little as
$2.13 per hour and count a portion of the worker's tips, the tip credit (up to
$5.12), toward the remaining balance of the $7.25 federal minimum wage.
The credit comes with conditions. The employer must inform the employee of the tip-credit
provisions; the employee's cash wage plus tips must actually reach the minimum wage each
workweek (the employer makes up any shortfall); and employees must retain their tips, subject
only to a valid tip pool among customarily tipped co-workers — managers and supervisors may
not share in it. Break any condition and the credit is lost, meaning the employer owes the
full minimum wage in cash for the affected hours. Tip-credit compliance failures —
invalid tip pools, missing notice, and side-work abuse — are among the most common claims in
restaurant wage
and hour litigation.
The Dual-Jobs Regulation
The foundational text is the DOL's dual-jobs regulation (29 C.F.R. § 531.56(e)),
which draws a line between one person holding two jobs and one tipped job that includes
related duties. A hotel employee who works as both a maintenance worker and a server is a
tipped employee only as to the serving job — no tip credit for the maintenance hours. By
contrast, a server who “spends part of her time cleaning and setting tables, toasting
bread, making coffee and occasionally washing dishes or glasses” is still engaged in a
tipped occupation, and those related duties can ride on the tipped wage.
The regulation answered the easy cases and begged the hard one: how much related-but-untipped
work is too much? A server assigned three hours of prep and cleaning around a two-hour dinner
rush is nominally doing “related duties” — but most of the shift produces no tips.
That gap is what the 80/20 rule tried to fill.
The 80/20 Rule — Rise, Codification, and Vacatur
Beginning with sub-regulatory guidance in the late 1980s, the DOL's answer was the
80/20 rule: an employer could take the tip credit for related, non-tip-producing duties
only if they occupied no more than 20% of the tipped employee's time; beyond that, the
excess hours had to be paid at the full minimum wage. Courts widely deferred to the guidance,
and 80/20 claims became a fixture of server collective actions. The rule's fortunes then
swung with administrations — withdrawn in 2018–2019, then revived and strengthened in a
2021 final rule that codified the 80/20 framework and added a 30-minute cap: any
continuous stretch of directly-supporting work longer than 30 minutes had to be paid at
full minimum wage regardless of weekly percentages.
In Restaurant Law Center v. U.S. Department of Labor (2024), the Fifth Circuit
vacated the 2021 rule nationwide, holding it inconsistent with the FLSA's text — a
decision issued shortly after the Supreme Court ended judicial deference to agency
interpretations. The DOL subsequently removed the vacated rule from the Code of Federal
Regulations, restoring the older dual-jobs text. The practical state today is unsettled:
there is no 80/20 regulation in force at the federal level, the dual-jobs regulation again
supplies the governing line, courts are working out how much of the older case law survives,
and some states impose their own stricter side-work limits. What has not changed: a tipped
employee assigned genuinely unrelated work, or side work so extensive it swallows the tipped
occupation, still has a claim — the fight is over where and how the line gets drawn.
States With No Tip Credit
The entire side-work problem is a creature of the tip credit — and several states simply do
not allow one. California, Washington, Oregon, Nevada, Minnesota, Montana, and Alaska
require employers to pay tipped employees the full state minimum wage in cash before
tips. In those states, an hour of rolling silverware pays the same wage as an hour of waiting
tables, so the 80/20 dispute largely evaporates; litigation there centers instead on tip
pooling, service charges, meal and rest breaks, and off-the-clock claims. Many other states
allow a tip credit but set higher tipped cash wages than the federal $2.13, so the size of the
stakes varies state by state.
How Side-Work Claims Become Collective Actions
Chain restaurants standardize everything — menus, recipes, and side-work checklists. That
standardization is what turns one server's complaint into a group case: when the same opening
and closing duties, staffing formulas, and tipped-wage policies apply across dozens or
hundreds of locations, every server and bartender has essentially the same claim. These cases
proceed as opt-in FLSA collective actions, often paired with state-law classes, seeking
the difference between the tipped wage and the full minimum wage for the disputed hours, plus
liquidated damages.
Side work is the non-serving labor tipped employees perform around their customer-facing duties: rolling silverware, brewing coffee and tea, stocking service stations, cutting fruit, portioning dressings, wiping menus, and cleaning before opening or after closing. It is real work — the dispute is over the pay rate, because side work performed on a tipped sub-minimum wage earns no tips while it is being done.
What is the tip credit?
Under the FLSA, an employer may pay a tipped employee a cash wage as low as $2.13 per hour and count a portion of the employee's tips — the "tip credit" — toward the rest of the $7.25 federal minimum wage. The credit is only available if the employee is properly notified, actually receives enough tips to reach the minimum, and keeps their tips (subject to a valid tip pool). If any condition fails, the employer owes the full minimum wage for those hours.
What was the 80/20 rule for tipped employees?
A limit on how much non-tipped work can be paid at the tipped sub-minimum wage. Under long-standing Department of Labor guidance, if a tipped employee spent more than 20% of their time on duties that do not produce tips, the employer could not take the tip credit for that excess time. A 2021 DOL rule codified the 80/20 approach and added a 30-minute cap on continuous non-tipped work. In 2024, the Fifth Circuit vacated that rule in Restaurant Law Center v. DOL, so there is currently no 80/20 regulation in force at the federal level — the area is governed by the older dual-jobs regulation and developing case law, and it remains unsettled.
Which states do not allow a tip credit?
Several states require employers to pay tipped employees the full state minimum wage in cash before tips, with no tip credit at all — including California, Washington, Oregon, Nevada, Minnesota, Montana, and Alaska. In those states the side-work fight mostly disappears, because every hour is already paid at full minimum wage; disputes there tend to center on tip pooling, service charges, and off-the-clock work instead.
How do side-work claims become collective actions?
Because chains standardize side work. When the same opening and closing checklists, staffing formulas, and tipped-wage policies apply across every location, one server's claim that they spent excessive unpaid or under-paid time on non-tipped duties looks like every co-worker's claim. Servers and bartenders then sue together in an FLSA collective action — which each worker must opt in to join — often combined with state-law class claims. Settlements typically pay back the wage difference for the disputed hours plus, under the FLSA, liquidated damages.
Get notified when new class actions open to claims
Join thousands of readers who get the latest class action settlements you may qualify for — delivered straight to your inbox.
About This Page
General legal-information about tipped side work and the tip credit, not legal advice.
OpenClassActions.com is a consumer news site and is not a law firm or a settlement
administrator. This area of law is genuinely unsettled following the 2024 vacatur of the DOL's
tipped-employee rule, and the rules also vary significantly by state. For the controlling
federal provisions, see the Fair Labor Standards Act, 29 C.F.R. § 531.56, and the
U.S. Department of Labor's tipped-employee guidance.
If you think your side work was underpaid, consult a qualified employment attorney in your
jurisdiction.
More on Wage & Hour Claims
Wage & Hour Class Actions: FLSA collective actions (opt-in) vs. Rule 23 classes (opt-out) — the hub guide for this cluster. Read the guide →
Wage Theft: The umbrella term — minimum-wage violations, unpaid overtime, tip theft, and illegal deductions. Learn more →
Off-the-Clock Work: Pre-shift prep done before clock-in must be paid when the employer knows about it. What it covers →
Independent Contractor Misclassification: The independent-contractor label that strips minimum-wage and overtime protections — and when it is unlawful. Read more →
