If you bought a burial plot or services at this Louisville cemetery between 1992 and 2017, you were part of a $1.25 million settlement over lost records and misplaced graves — the claim window has now closed.
What Was This Settlement About?
St. Stephen's Cemetery Association agreed to establish a $1,250,000 settlement fund to resolve a long-running class action over how a Catholic cemetery in Louisville, Kentucky kept — or failed to keep — its burial records. The lawsuit, filed in 2017, alleged gross negligence by the cemetery, its board members, and its caretaker for losing records that identified where bodies were buried, interring bodies in improper locations, and failing to follow Kentucky cemetery laws governing the proper interment of bodies and cremated remains.The case is captioned Tina Seaton, et al. v. St. Stephen's Cemetery Association, et al., Case No. 17-CI-001663, in the Jefferson Circuit Court, Division One, in Louisville. St. Stephen's Cemetery Association denied all of the allegations and denied any wrongdoing in connection with the cemetery services it provided. The court did not decide in favor of either side; instead, both sides agreed to settle to avoid the costs and risks of a trial while allowing class members to recover compensation.
Who Was Covered?
The settlement class was defined as all persons who purchased — and/or who are the next of kin or the surviving spouse of a person who purchased — a burial plot and/or services from St. Stephen's Cemetery between January 1, 1992 and February 24, 2017.Several groups were excluded, including officers, directors, agents, employees, and owners of St. Stephen's Cemetery Association and their immediate families; the judge assigned to the case and the judge's staff and families; anyone who timely opted out of the class; and anyone who had already obtained separate legal representation or commenced a separate lawsuit over the same claims as of the certification date.
Free settlement alerts
Get notified when new class actions open to claims
Join thousands of readers who get the latest class action settlements you may qualify for — delivered straight to your inbox.
How Much Could Class Members Get?
There was no flat per-person payment. The $1.25 million fund first covered notice and administration costs, court-approved attorneys' fees and expenses, and service awards to the class representatives. The remaining money was then paid to class members who submitted valid claims, on a pro-rata basis.Each valid claimant's share was calculated from factors including the number of graves purchased, the number of relatives buried at the cemetery during the relevant period, and the documentation provided. Any funds left over after valid claims were paid were directed to cy pres (charitable) recipients rather than reverting to the cemetery.
Was Proof Required?
Yes. To receive a payment, a class member had to submit a completed and signed claim form, identify each grave for which a claim was being made, and provide documentation showing class membership. The settlement administrator could follow up to request additional information or documents to verify a claim.Anyone filing on behalf of a deceased person faced an additional documentation step: they had to establish their authority to act — for example, as a personal representative — and provide a statement under oath identifying the decedent, describing their relationship to the decedent, and confirming their authority to submit the claim. Because filing required these purchase and next-of-kin records, this was a proof-required settlement, not a no-documentation cash claim.
Current Status — Paid Out (Checks Mailed September 2025)
The court held its final approval (fairness) hearing on March 24, 2025, before Judge Eric J. Haner in Jefferson Circuit Court, and granted final approval of the settlement on March 28, 2025. In the same order, the court approved $416,625 in attorneys' fees and $75,688.89 in litigation costs, to be paid from the settlement fund.With the settlement final, the administrator moved to distribution. The official settlement website announced that it was aiming to mail checks to approved claimants by September 26, 2025, and claimants publicly reported receiving checks shortly afterward, around late September 2025. Individual amounts varied with each claim — one recipient reported a payment of roughly $2,000 — because payouts were calculated pro-rata from the number of graves, the number of relatives buried, and the supporting documentation submitted.
Important: the claim window for this settlement has closed and new claims are no longer being accepted. Initial settlement checks appear to have been mailed in late September 2025. This page is maintained for reference only; the official settlement website remains the authoritative source for any further distribution updates.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who was eligible for the St. Stephen's Cemetery settlement?
The settlement class included all people who purchased — or who are the next of kin or surviving spouse of a person who purchased — a burial plot and/or services from St. Stephen's Cemetery in Louisville, Kentucky between January 1, 1992 and February 24, 2017.
How much was the St. Stephen's Cemetery settlement?
St. Stephen's Cemetery Association agreed to establish a $1,250,000 settlement fund. After notice and administration costs, attorneys' fees and costs, and service awards, the remainder was paid to valid claimants on a pro-rata basis, with any leftover funds going to cy pres recipients.
How were the payment amounts calculated?
Valid claimants received a pro-rata share of the net settlement fund based on factors such as the number of graves purchased, the number of relatives buried at the cemetery during the relevant period, and the documentation provided. There was no flat per-person amount.
Was proof required to file a claim?
Yes. Claimants had to submit a completed, signed claim form, identify each grave at issue, and provide documentation establishing class membership. Anyone filing on behalf of a deceased person also had to provide documentation of their authority to act, under oath.
Can I still file a claim for the St. Stephen's Cemetery settlement?
No. The claim window has closed. The court granted final approval on March 28, 2025, and the administrator mailed payments to class members who submitted timely claim forms, with checks reported around late September 2025. New claims are no longer being accepted.
Sources
- Notice of Class Action Settlement — Tina Seaton, et al. v. St. Stephen's Cemetery Association, et al., Case No. 17-CI-001663 (Jefferson Circuit Court, Division One, Louisville, KY)
- Official settlement website — KYCemeterySettlement.com
