Insurance · Claims Open

Sentry and Dairyland $2.75 Million New Mexico Underinsured Motorist Settlement — Up to $25,000 for Offset Claims, Automatic Premium Refunds

Published November 20, 2026

New Mexico drivers who bought uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage from Sentry, Dairyland or their affiliated insurers between October 2010 and December 2022 may qualify for the $2.75 million Coto v. Sentry Insurance settlement. Policyholders whose underinsured motorist claim was reduced by the at-fault driver’s insurance payment can claim up to $25,000 by January 8, 2027; other policyholders receive an automatic partial premium refund.

Scrabble tiles spelling insurance

Current Status

Claims are open. The deadline for Offset Subclass Claim Forms is January 8, 2027, online or postmarked by that date. The court-approved notice is dated September 24, 2026. The opt-out deadline is December 24, 2026, and objections are due December 9, 2026. The settlement website does not list a final fairness hearing date, and nothing is paid until the court grants final approval.

Status Claims Open Claim by January 8, 2027 · online or postmarked
Claim Deadline January 8, 2027 Offset claims only · premium refunds are automatic
Estimated Payout Up to $25,000 · or a premium refund $25,000 cap for offset claims · refunds automatic for other policyholders
Proof Required Unique ID and PIN to file online From the mailed postcard · claims checked against Sentry’s records

What Changed Recently?

Sentry Insurance Company and its affiliates agreed to pay $2,750,000 to settle Coto v. Dairyland Insurance Company, Sentry Insurance Company, No. 25-cv-00160, in the U.S. District Court for the District of New Mexico, and the court authorized notice to class members. The lawsuit alleged that Sentry did not properly tell New Mexico policyholders that underinsured motorist (UIM) benefits are by law reduced, or “offset,” by what the at-fault driver’s insurer pays. The complaint brought breach of contract, bad faith, negligent misrepresentation and New Mexico Unfair Trade Practices Act and Unfair Insurance Practices Act claims.

The settling insurers are Dairyland Insurance Company, Sentry Insurance Company, Peak Property and Casualty Insurance Corporation, Viking Insurance Company of Wisconsin and Sentry Select Insurance Company. Sentry says it complied with its policies and the law and denies all material allegations.

Who Qualifies?

The settlement class covers two overlapping groups, both limited to New Mexico auto policies issued by Sentry with an effective date before January 1, 2022: If the at-fault driver had no liability insurance at all, the claim was an uninsured motorist claim, which the notice says does not qualify for the Offset Subclass payment.

How Much Can You Get?

Offset Subclass members who file a valid claim receive up to $25,000, reduced proportionally if valid claims exceed the portion of the fund set aside for them.

Everyone else in the class receives a partial refund of their UM/UIM premiums. Its size depends on how much the person paid in UM/UIM premiums during the class period, administration costs, court-approved fees and awards, and whatever is left over from the offset-claim portion. The notice gives no estimate.

Class counsel will ask for attorneys’ fees of no more than one-third of the fund and costs of no more than $6,200, plus a $10,000 incentive award, all paid from the $2.75 million fund.

What Proof or Notice ID Is Required?

To file online, an Offset Subclass member needs the Unique ID and PIN printed on the postcard notice. People who were not identified as potential Offset Subclass members, or who lost their postcard, can download the Claim Form from the settlement website’s Documents page and mail it. The notice says every claim is verified against Sentry’s business records and only valid claims are paid. The premium refund needs nothing: it is mailed automatically.

What Is the Deadline?

Offset Subclass Claim Forms are due January 8, 2027, submitted online or postmarked by that date. Requests to be excluded must be postmarked by December 24, 2026, and notices of intent to object by December 9, 2026. Under the notice, a claimant whose address changes within 60 days after the settlement’s effective date must update it with the administrator or risk missing the payment.

How Do You Take Action?



What Happens Next?

The court will decide at a final fairness hearing whether to approve the settlement; the settlement website had not posted the hearing date as of November 20, 2026. Offset claim payments and premium refund checks are issued only after final approval. Epiq is the settlement administrator.

Sources and Verification



Questions

Who qualifies for the Sentry and Dairyland New Mexico underinsured motorist settlement?

People who bought or paid premiums for a New Mexico auto policy from Sentry, Dairyland or their affiliated insurers with uninsured/underinsured motorist (UM/UIM) coverage between October 1, 2010 and December 31, 2022, on a policy that took effect before January 1, 2022. A smaller Offset Subclass covers people whose underinsured motorist claim from an accident in that period was reduced by what the at-fault driver’s insurer paid.

How much is the Sentry UIM settlement payment?

Offset Subclass members who file a valid claim can receive up to $25,000, reduced proportionally if claims exceed the money set aside for them. Other class members get an automatic partial premium refund based on the UM/UIM premiums they paid; the notice does not give an estimate.

What is the claim deadline for the Coto v. Sentry settlement?

Claim Forms for Offset Subclass payments must be submitted online or postmarked by January 8, 2027. The opt-out deadline is December 24, 2026, and objections are due December 9, 2026.

Do I need a claim form to get the Sentry premium refund?

No. Class members who are not claiming an accident-related offset payment do not file anything; the notice says they will automatically receive a check in the mail after final approval.

What if the at-fault driver had no insurance?

Then the claim was an uninsured motorist claim, not an underinsured one, and the notice says it is not eligible for the up-to-$25,000 Offset Subclass payment. A policyholder in that situation may still receive the automatic premium refund.

What is the Schmick offset?

The notice describes it as reducing underinsured motorist benefits by the amount available from the at-fault driver’s liability insurance. The lawsuit alleged Sentry did not properly tell New Mexico policyholders that this reduction applies, so UIM coverage could pay less than they expected. Sentry denies wrongdoing.

Official Settlement Notice

Your browser does not support viewing PDFs inline. Download the PDF.


For more class actions keep scrolling below.
Settlement Amount $2,750,000
Case Title Coto v. Dairyland Insurance Company, Sentry Insurance Company
Case Number 1:25-cv-00160
Court U.S. District Court, District of New Mexico
Final Approval Hearing Not posted
Administrator Epiq
Official Website NMUIMClassSettlement.com

More Insurance Settlements